Artificial intelligence chatbots promoted to help shoppers navigate Black Friday sales frequently deliver expired links, inaccurate prices and wrong product specifications, tests of leading models have shown.
A test of the free versions of OpenAI's ChatGPT, Claude, Google's Gemini and Amazon's Alexa tasked with finding a 55-inch television bargain yielded mixed and often misleading outcomes. While technology companies have rolled out dedicated shopping features ahead of discount events, the tools repeatedly directed users to unavailable stock and inconsistent pricing data.
In the test, ChatGPT suggested four television options, but two linked to retailers John Lewis and Richer Sounds where the products were no longer listed online, while another was £150 over budget and out of stock. Claude recommended models that led to dead pages on Richer Sounds as well as year-old round-ups of 2025 discounts. Gemini provided accurate prices for some models but offered no direct store links and cited Currys at £60 below its actual price. Alexa returned accurate pricing but restricted its search solely to Amazon's catalogue.
Survey data from YouGov across 19 countries indicated that the UK ranked second-last in consumer use of AI for retail, with 36 percent of surveyed shoppers intending to avoid AI tools completely around Black Friday. Despite that hesitancy, tech firms have expanded commerce capabilities, including Amazon's Alexa for Shopping in the UK, OpenAI's Shopping Research tool, and Google's Universal Cart in the United States.
Consumer advocates warn that verifying chatbot results often consumes more time than traditional searching. Hannah Walsh, a senior researcher at consumer group Which?, noted: "If you ask ChatGPT for a list of 10 laptops under £400 and seven of the results are priced higher, you've likely wasted a good chunk of time going through them to discover the bot gave you only three options."
Business adviser Naureen Mohammed warned that failing to refresh retail data leaves shoppers vulnerable to stale information. If businesses do not update prices during discount periods, "last year's prices are served up as today's deals," Mohammed said, advising shoppers not to accept AI outputs at face value.
Tech journalist Alex Hughes, who previously evaluated automated AI searches for television deals, noted that he would probably not rely on the tool again for live sales. While automated searches saved time, Hughes said, "when you're trying to deal with something like live price data... it will be inconsistent and quite often incorrect."